Does Astrology Work? What the Research Actually Shows (and Why People Still Love It)
Controlled tests, including a famous 1985 Nature study, find astrology does no better than chance. Yet 3 in 10 Americans consult it. Here's the evidence.
Astrology does not work as a predictive or diagnostic tool in any test that has been done under controlled conditions. In the most famous experiment, published in Nature in 1985, astrologers could not match people's birth charts to their personality profiles better than chance. Large studies on marriage and divorce show the same. What astrology demonstrably does offer is a shared symbolic language, a ritual of self-reflection and entertainment – which is why around three in ten Americans still consult it.
This article lays out the main evidence, explains why astrology feels accurate anyway, and suggests a sensible way to enjoy it.
What counts as "working"?
Astrology makes several kinds of claims, and they need different tests:
| Claim | How you could test it |
|---|---|
| Your chart describes your personality | Can astrologers match charts to independently measured personalities? |
| Compatible charts make better couples | Do "compatible" couples marry more or divorce less? |
| Transits predict events | Do events cluster around specific planetary positions? |
| Sun signs shape character | Do personality scores differ by birth month beyond seasonal effects? |
The most rigorous research has focused on the first two, because they produce clear, measurable outcomes.
The 1985 Nature double-blind test
Physicist Shawn Carlson designed a test with input from astrologers themselves. As summarised in the Wikipedia article on Carlson:
- 28 astrologers, nominated by the National Council for Geocosmic Research, took part.
- They agreed beforehand that the protocol was a fair test of natal astrology.
- They chose the personality test used – the California Psychological Inventory.
- Their task was to match over 100 natal charts to the correct personality profiles.
The result, published on 5 December 1985: the astrologers did no better than chance, and they were no more accurate when they were confident in a match. Astrologers have criticised the statistics and some details of the design, and the debate has continued for decades, but no comparably controlled test has reversed the outcome.
The Swedish marriage study
In 2020, Jonas Helgertz and Kirk Scott at Lund University used individual-level Swedish register data covering 1968 to 2001 to ask two questions: are astrologically "compatible" couples more likely to marry, and are they less likely to divorce? Their paper in Genus found no consistent evidence for either. For how synastry is meant to work, see our explainer on comparing two birth charts.
The physics question
There is also no known mechanism. Gravity and light from distant planets are tiny at Earth, and phenomena astrology attaches meaning to are often perspective effects. Mercury retrograde is a good example: the Planetary Society explains that Mercury only appears to move backwards because it overtakes Earth, and that there is no scientific evidence any planet's apparent retrograde affects people.
How many people use astrology anyway?
Quite a lot. Pew Research Center surveyed 9,593 US adults between 21 and 27 October 2024 and published the results in May 2025:
| Finding | Share of US adults |
|---|---|
| Consult astrology, tarot or a fortune teller at least yearly | 30% |
| Consult astrology or horoscopes at least yearly | 28% |
| Believe in astrology | 27% (29% in 2017) |
| Women who believe in astrology | 35% |
| Men who believe in astrology | 18% |
| Do it mostly "just for fun" | 20% |
| Mostly believe it gives helpful insights | 10% |
| Rely on it "a lot" for major decisions | 1% |
In other words, most users approach it lightly – the gap between "consult" and "rely on" is enormous.
Why it feels accurate
Several well-documented psychological effects explain why readings ring true:
- The Barnum (Forer) effect. Vague, flattering descriptions ("you can be sociable but also need time alone") feel personal to almost everyone.
- Confirmation bias. We remember the hits and forget the misses.
- Self-attribution. People who know their sign may come to describe themselves in its terms.
- The reading as conversation. A good reader – human or app – reflects back what you bring. That can be genuinely helpful as self-reflection, even if the stars play no part.
So why bother?
Because "not predictive" doesn't mean "not valuable". Astrology, coffee-cup reading and tarot are cultural traditions with long histories. They give people a vocabulary for talking about moods, relationships and choices; a reason to pause each morning; a ritual to share with friends. Turkish coffee reading is part of a tradition UNESCO lists as intangible heritage precisely because of its role in hospitality and conversation.
The problems start when the ritual replaces expertise – choosing medical treatment, making investments or ending a relationship because of a chart.
A healthy way to enjoy it
- Frame it as entertainment or reflection, not forecasting.
- Use it to ask questions, not to receive answers.
- Never let it override professional advice on health, money or law.
- Be wary of anyone charging large sums or claiming certainty.
- Notice how it makes you feel. If it creates anxiety, step away.
Falci is built in that spirit: its readings are labelled as entertainment and are not medical, legal or financial advice – a modern take on a cultural ritual. If you're curious how three different traditions describe the same birthday, our astrology calendar 2027 is a gentle place to start.
Falci reads your cup from a photo and your chart through three traditions – as a ritual for fun, not a forecast.
Download on the App StoreFrequently asked questions
Has astrology ever been scientifically tested?
Yes, many times. In the best-known test, published in Nature in 1985, astrologers tried to match birth charts to personality profiles and did no better than chance. Large population studies, such as a 2020 Swedish study on marriage and divorce, also found no consistent effect.
How many people believe in astrology?
A Pew Research Center survey of 9,593 US adults in October 2024 found that 27% believe in astrology and 28% consult astrology or horoscopes at least once a year.
Is it harmful to enjoy astrology if it isn't scientific?
For most people, no. Pew found that most users engage mainly for fun and only 1% rely on it a lot for major decisions. Problems arise when it replaces medical, financial or legal advice.
Sources
- 3 in 10 Americans consult astrology, tarot cards or fortune tellers — Pew Research Center (2025-05-21)
- Shawn Carlson — Wikipedia
- The validity of astrological predictions on marriage and divorce — Lund University (2020-10-01)
- What does Mercury in retrograde actually mean? — The Planetary Society